True Crime All The Time Unsolved

On February 23rd, 1997, the bodies of 33-year-old Kimberly Stephan and 55-year-old Dennis Young were found shot to death inside Dennis’s home in Greenville, Ohio. At the time of her death, Kimberly was in the process of finalizing her divorce from her abusive husband, who police identified as the prime suspect. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the murders of Kimberly Stephan and Dennis Young, a case that is very close to home for us. The authorities don't normally use the word 'suspect' lightly, but they have called Bob Stephan a suspect from the outset of the...

Jermain Charlo, a young mother from Montana, vanished in 2018 after a night out with her ex-boyfriend. Her last confirmed movements were captured on surveillance footage, but what happened to Jermain remains a mystery. 23-year-old Jermain Charlo lived on the Flathead Reservation as a member of the Confederated Salish and Kootenai tribes. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the disappearance of Jermain Charlo. Jermain had two sons, Jacob and Thomas, with her ex-boyfriend, Michael DeFrance. Michael and Jermain had a rocky relationship, and he was arrested twice for domestic violence. The two went out on the night Je...

A small town in Arkansas was shocked when two best friends were found dead on the train tracks. Authorities initially believed their death was an accident, but their families pushed for a second investigation. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the deaths of Don Henry and Kevin Ives. Their families didn't agree with the conclusions the authorities reached, and for good reasons. There was conflicting evidence and eyewitness accounts that contradicted those conclusions. There are also a lot of theories in this case that range from corrupt politicians and law enforcement to drug cartels.<b...

Marilyn “Niqui” McCown disappeared just a few weeks before her wedding while doing her laundry on a Sunday afternoon. Her family does not believe she would leave on her own. She had her fiancé and the wedding to look forward to, and a daughter she loved very much. Over twenty years later, Niqui remains missing.Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the disappearance of Marilyn McCown. She lived in the Richmond, Indiana area, but the case has many ties to our hometown of Dayton, Ohio. Marilyn was apparently being harassed by two men at the laundromat on th...

On June 12th, 1985, Jule Caylor dropped his wife Dottie off at a train station, where she supposedly purchased a ticket to visit a friend. However, there was no evidence that Dottie ever boarded the train. As investigators learned more about the Caylors’ troubled marriage, they began to suspect Jule had something to do with his wife’s disappearance. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the disappearance of Dottie Caylor. There seem to have been many holes in the story that Jules told the police, and he has never left their radar. But, as of yet, no one h...

Lester Eubanks was sentenced to death for the November 1965 murder and attempted rape of 14-year-old Mary Ellen Deener. After his sentence was commuted to life in prison, he was able to charm his way into the prison’s honor program, which gave him the opportunity to escape during an outing in December 1973. Lester has been on the run ever since, and is currently on the U.S. Marshals’ Most Wanted list. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss Lester Eubanks. How does a man once on death row end up escaping from custody and eluding the authorities for o...

Angelica Maria Gandara went missing in July 1985 while making the short walk from her grandmother’s house to her family home in Temple, Texas. Forty years later, authorities have identified two strong suspects, but no arrests have been made. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the disappearance of Angelica Gandara. These two suspects are very interesting, and both have murderous pasts. One suspect, Ramiro Ibarra, was close to the family and later married Angelica's aunt. Ibarra was convicted of murdering a 16-year-old girl. The other suspect, David Penton, was convicted of multiple murders in the Dallas are...

On January 5th, 1981, Jeff Neilson returned to his home in Moore, Oklahoma, from a day of classes to find his wife of five months, Tracey Neilson, dead from multiple stab wounds. Over four decades later, Tracey’s murder remains unsolved. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the murder of Tracey Neilson. Tracey was a native of Texas who met and fell in love with Jeff at Oklahoma State University. Everyone who knew her said she was a loving and caring person. Not a single person knew who would have wanted her dead. The authorities had two imp...

In October 2023, Nancy Ng disappeared while kayaking on Lake Atitlán in Guatemala. Guatemalan officials believe Nancy drowned, but her family has questioned accounts from witnesses who were present the day she went missing. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the disappearance of Nancy Ng. The group that Nancy was with all left the day after she disappeared, which seemed suspicious to some, especially Nancy's family. And the last person known to be with Nancy didn't want to talk to the family, but did talk to the local police and the FBI. Did something nefarious happen to...

52-year-old Lynn Messer went missing in 2014. Two years later, her body was found on her family’s farm property in Bloomsdale, Missouri. Her husband, Kerry Messer, has been the subject of much speculation and scrutiny since her disappearance.Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the disappearance and death of Lynn Messer. The Messers had two sons who were adults when Lynn disappeared. They seem to be dubious about some of the claims their father has made over the years. One of the big issues is when a relationship with a woman began. The timing of that cou...

Sheryl Warner was murdered in 2005 after opening her door to someone whom she thought was a stranger in need of assistance. Twenty years later, the case remains unsolved. Friends and family said Sheryl would have helped anyone in need, and it's possible someone took advantage of her kindness.Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the murder of Sheryl Warner. She was killed in a very brutal and sadistic manner. In 2006, Ray Joseph Dandridge and his uncle, Ricky Javon Gray, were arrested in Philadelphia for murders that bore very similar characteristics to the murder of Sheryl Warner...

Dorothy Kilgallen was a journalist and TV personality known for covering high-profile murder cases and appearing on game shows. She died of an overdose at age 52. At the time of her death, she was investigating the assassination of John F. Kennedy, leading many to believe her death was not an accident.Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the death of Dorothy Kilgallen. The number of pills in her system doesn't lend to an accidental overdose, which leads to two possibilities. Dorothy carried around with her a portfolio of her research on the assassination of JFK. She...

Travis Decker was described as an active father who loved his three daughters. Everything seemed normal when he picked the girls up for a scheduled visitation on May 30th, 2025, but Travis did not return the girls on time. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the tragic murders of Paityn, Evelyn, and Olivia Decker. Days later, police found their bodies in a remote campground. Travis Decker was missing, and a massive manhunt ensued. Sightings poured in from all over the country, and the authorities had to track them all down. There was evidence that Travis was responsible...

Andre Jones was an 18-year-old from Jackson, Mississippi, who was arrested at a sobriety checkpoint days before he was supposed to start his freshman year of college. Shortly after his arrest, Andre was found hanging in a prison shower. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the death of Andre Jones. Officials said Andre ended his life because he was despondent about being caught driving a stolen vehicle and facing the prospect of going to prison. However, his family argued that Andre’s death was a lynching disguised as a suicide. Many questions surround this case.<...

In October 2000, two women named Mary Morris were murdered days apart in Harris County, Texas. Authorities have said they haven’t found a link between the cases, both of which remain unsolved, but the families say the coincidences are too suspicious to ignore. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the Mary Morris murders. The body of Mary Lou Morris was found burned beyond recognition in her car. Three days later, Mary McGinnis Morris was found dead inside her car. Both women had husbands and families and were said to be well-liked with no known enemies. The sim...

17-year-old Randy Leach was reported missing on April 16th, 1988, after he failed to come home from a high school party. Thirty-seven years later, neither Randy nor the car he was driving has been found. There have been many rumors in this case, from drug deals gone wrong to satanic cult activity, but few real leads for investigators to follow up on. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the disappearance of Randy Leach. As with most cases in the 1980s, the possibility of satanic activity existed. People came forward to say all sorts of things related to R...

21-year-old Maura Murray went missing from Haverhill, New Hampshire, on February 9th, 2004, moments after crashing her car in the snow. Over twenty years later, there is still no trace of her. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the infamous missing persons case of Maura Murray. This case has drawn nationwide attention. Amateur websleuths on the internet continue to talk about it, and it has spawned several podcasts devoted solely to the case. There are many mysteries surrounding Maura's disappearance, and even more theories about what happened to her. You can help s...

16-year-old Judy Rawlings was reported missing from her family’s home on October 5th, 2001. Two weeks later, her body was found in the woods. Police have identified a suspect, but the murder remains unsolved over twenty years later. Join Mike and Morf as they discuss the murder of Judy Rawlings. What is tougher on the family of a murder victim: to have no idea who the perpetrator is, or to have an idea, but the police are unable to charge that person? There is a person very much on the police radar in this case, and many sig...

For over a decade, there have been questions regarding the death of Michelle O’Connell, a young mother from Florida who was in a relationship with a sheriff’s deputy. Her death is officially declared a suicide, but several experts believe the evidence points to a homicide. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the death of Michelle O'Connell. Michelle had told friends and family that she was going to end the relationship with her boyfriend. They had tickets to a concert, and Michelle decided to go with him, but intended to break up with him that night...

In the ‘70s and ‘80s, three Florida women went missing under suspiciously similar circumstances. The women didn’t know each other. Their only connection was a man named Cleveland Hill Jr. All three women went missing after they ended their affairs with Hill. Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss the murders of Margaret Dash, Retha Hiers, and Donyelle Johnson. All three of these women had relationships with Cleveland Hill, ended them, and then subsequently went missing. It's tough to write that off as a coincidence. Hill had a long history of violence and once shot both his wif...