Best of 2025 | Carrie Culberson: The True Story of Ohio’s Infamous No-Body Murder Case

Carrie Culberson was just 22 years old when she vanished from Blanchester, Ohio in August 1996. What followed became one of the state’s most haunting true crime cases: a young woman missing, a violent boyfriend at the center of suspicion, a town shaken by fear and rumor, and a murder conviction without a body. For this Best of 2025 revisit, we’re returning to one of the most gripping and unforgettable episodes of Terrifying & True. 

This story has all the elements that make a case impossible to forget: a terrifying patte...