Nightmare on Horton Road: The Kelly Ann Tinyes Case

This source details the 1989 murder of 13-year-old Kelly Ann Tinyes, a tragedy that devastated the quiet community of Valley Stream, New York. After the young girl vanished from her home, her mutilated body was discovered in the basement of her neighbors, the Golib family. The investigation ultimately led to the conviction of Robert Golib, though the victim’s family remains convinced that his younger brother and friends were also involved. Decades later, the case continues to haunt the neighborhood as the Tinyes family fights to keep the killer behind bars. The narrative emphasizes the lasting trauma experienced by the survivors and the int...